Multiphase Optimization Trial of Incentives for Veterans to Encourage Walking

Last updated on July 2021

Recruitment

Recruitment Status: Not yet recruiting
Estimated Enrollment: Same as current

Summary

Conditions

Body Mass Index
Depression
Exercise
Hypertension
Motivation
Sedentary Behavior
Walking

Type

Interventional

Phase

Not Applicable

Design

Allocation: RandomizedIntervention Model: Factorial AssignmentIntervention Model Description: The MOST trial design involves optimizing an intervention before it is tested against a usual control. It is optimized in that the various components of the intervention are tested against one another in a screening phase to assess which components add value to the intervention, and then only the valuable components are included in the final intervention. It is especially useful when an intervention has many potential combinations of components, as is the case with incentives. In a traditional trial, researchers would use theory or evidence from prior studies to choose an incentive design and test this package against usual care. Even if this package outperforms usual care in a randomized trial, the investigators cannot tell whether it was optimal. Some components could have provided no benefit or delivered in too small a dose to be effective. Other components could have been detrimental to subjects. There is no way to know if the components are all tested as a single package.Masking: Single (Investigator)Masking Description: Data will be masked to the principal investigator.Primary Purpose: Health Services Research

Participation Requirements

Age: Between 50 years and 69 years
Gender: Both males and females

Description

The investigators propose to fill the research gaps through a Multiphase Optimization Strategy (MOST) trial of incentives for walking. A MOST trial is ideally suited for situations in which a proposed intervention has many potential intervention components. A MOST trial consists of three phases. A screening phase trial is used to efficiently identify-through a factorial designed randomized trial-the effective components of a complex intervention like incentives. A refining phase trial tests the optimal dose (size or duration) of the incentives. A confirmatory phase trial tests the optimal components and dose against a usual care control. The goal of the proposed study is to conduct the screening phase trial in 128 Veterans to identify the optimal components of incentives for increasing walking among physically inactive Veterans. All Veterans in this phase will be given various components of incentives for increasing average steps per day to 7,000 steps over a 12-week habit-building period, and then maintaining the increase through a 12-week habit maintenance period. The specific aims are: Aim 1: Conduct a 24 factorial designed screening-phase trial of incentives for increasing average steps per day to 7,000 steps over 12 weeks among physically inactive Veterans. Every patient in the trial will be given a Fitbit Inspire activity monitor and assigned to a group that receives different components of incentives. The investigators will test four different incentive factors: 1) lottery vs. loss framed incentives, 2) financial vs. non-financial incentives, 3) a pre-commitment postcard reminder of a Veteran's stated intrinsic reason for commitment to PA vs. no pre-commitment postcard, and 4) a request for PA advice from a Veteran on staying active vs. no request. The first factor has never been tested in a population like the VA. Factors 2-4 are designed specifically to sustain the effects of incentives after the incentive is removed. Factor 4 is a novel hypothesis that has never been tested outside of educational research: specifically, that asking for advice from a Veteran is more motivating than giving advice to them, even if that Veteran is struggling with low physical activity themselves. The primary outcome is change in steps per week from baseline to week 24. Aim 2. Conduct cost analyses and qualitative interviews. The cost of administering each component and qualitative assessments of the acceptability of each component to trial participants will inform the decision of which components to retain for the subsequent refining and confirmatory phase trials. Aim 3. Convene an expert panel to choose components for the next phases of the MOST trial. The panel will weigh each component in terms of its effect on step counts (Aim 1), administrative costs and participant-reported qualitative assessments (Aim 2), and the strength of the theoretical basis for the component's effect on physical activity.

Tracking Information

NCT #: NCT04518943
Collaborators: Not Provided
Investigators: Principal Investigator: Paul L. Hebert, PhD BA VA Puget Sound Health Care System Seattle Division, Seattle, WA